Last updated:

Which cybersecurity certification should you take?

Choose by the job you do or want next. In CertArc's guidance, security managers start with CISM, security leaders and architects with experience across several areas start with CISSP, and IT auditors start with CISA. The AI credentials come after one of those: AAISM needs an active CISM or CISSP, and AAIA needs CISA or a listed audit designation. If you are new to security, an entry certification comes first.

Fees, exam formats and experience rules checked against ISC2 and ISACA, most recently on 7 November 2026. Sources are listed at the end.

These five credentials are for people who already work in security, audit or risk. Each one asks for years of experience or an existing certification, and each exam rewards a different way of thinking about the same problem. Picking the one that matches your role matters more than picking the one that sounds hardest.

The advice on which certification to take is CertArc's own guidance, and the page says so wherever it gives it.

Choose by the job you do

Find the role closest to yours today. “Start with” is where most people in that role begin; “Then” is the usual next step.

  • Security manager, programme lead or aspiring CISO

    Start with: CISM

    Then: AAISM if you run AI programmes; CISSP for technical breadth

    CISM tests how a manager runs the security programme: governance, risk, the programme itself and incident management.

  • Security leader, architect or consultant working across several areas

    Start with: CISSP

    Then: CISM if you move into management; AAISM for AI security

    CISSP spans eight domains, from risk management to software security, for experienced practitioners, managers and executives; ISC2 positions it for roles up to CISO.

  • IT auditor, internal auditor or assurance lead

    Start with: CISA

    Then: AAIA to audit AI systems; CISM if you move into security management

    CISA tests the audit process and how you judge controls on evidence, from planning to follow-up.

  • GRC or risk analyst

    Start with: CISM for security risk programmes, or CISA for assurance and compliance testing

    Then: CRISC if your role is mostly IT risk (CertArc does not prepare for CRISC)

    GRC roles split between running the risk programme and testing it. Match the credential to the half you do.

  • AI governance or AI security lead

    Start with: AAISM, once you hold CISM or CISSP

    Then: AAIA if you also audit AI

    AAISM is open only to active CISM or CISSP holders and tests how AI is governed, risk-managed and controlled.

  • Auditor of AI systems

    Start with: AAIA, once you hold CISA or a listed designation

    Then: AAISM if you hold CISM or CISSP and move into AI security management

    AAIA applies audit judgement to AI governance, operations and the tools auditors use.

  • New to security, with under two years in the field

    Start with: An entry certification such as CompTIA Security+ or ISC2 Certified in Cybersecurity (CC)

    Then: One of the five above once you have the experience

    CISSP, CISM and CISA expect about five years of relevant work, so an entry certification is the honest first step.

The five certifications at a glance

CertificationBuilt forTo certifyExamExam feeEach year after
CISSPISC2Security leaders, managers and senior practitioners across eight domains, in roles up to CISOFive years of cumulative, full-time work in two or more of the eight domains; a degree or an approved credential can count for one yearComputerized adaptive test, 100 to 150 items, up to 3 hoursUS$749US$135; 120 CPE credits every three years
CISMISACASecurity managers, programme leads and aspiring CISOs who run the security programmeFive years of information security management work across at least three of the four domains, within the 10 years before you apply; up to two years can be waived150 multiple-choice questions in 4 hoursUS$575 member, US$760 non-member, plus US$50 to apply after passingUS$45 member, US$85 non-member; 20 CPE hours a year and 120 every three years
CISAISACAIT auditors, internal auditors and assurance leads who judge controls on evidenceFive years of work in IS or IT audit, control, assurance or security; up to three years can be waived150 multiple-choice questions in 4 hoursUS$575 member, US$760 non-member, plus US$50 to apply after passingUS$45 member, US$85 non-member; 20 CPE hours a year and 120 every three years
AAISMISACASecurity managers who govern and secure AI systemsAn active CISM or CISSP; no separate years-of-experience rule90 multiple-choice questions in 150 minutesUS$459 member, US$599 non-member, plus US$50 to apply after passingUS$20 member, US$35 non-member; 10 CPE hours a year and 30 every three years
AAIAISACAAuditors who audit AI systems and the controls around themAn active CISA, or one of ISACA's listed audit and accounting designations (such as CIA, US CPA or ACCA) with an IT audit or advisory role90 multiple-choice questions in 150 minutesUS$459 member, US$599 non-member, plus US$50 to apply after passingUS$20 member, US$35 non-member; 10 CPE hours a year and 30 every three years

CISSP ISC2

Built for
Security leaders, managers and senior practitioners across eight domains, in roles up to CISO
To certify
Five years of cumulative, full-time work in two or more of the eight domains; a degree or an approved credential can count for one year
Exam
Computerized adaptive test, 100 to 150 items, up to 3 hours
Exam fee
US$749
Each year after
US$135; 120 CPE credits every three years

CISM ISACA

Built for
Security managers, programme leads and aspiring CISOs who run the security programme
To certify
Five years of information security management work across at least three of the four domains, within the 10 years before you apply; up to two years can be waived
Exam
150 multiple-choice questions in 4 hours
Exam fee
US$575 member, US$760 non-member, plus US$50 to apply after passing
Each year after
US$45 member, US$85 non-member; 20 CPE hours a year and 120 every three years

CISA ISACA

Built for
IT auditors, internal auditors and assurance leads who judge controls on evidence
To certify
Five years of work in IS or IT audit, control, assurance or security; up to three years can be waived
Exam
150 multiple-choice questions in 4 hours
Exam fee
US$575 member, US$760 non-member, plus US$50 to apply after passing
Each year after
US$45 member, US$85 non-member; 20 CPE hours a year and 120 every three years

AAISM ISACA

Built for
Security managers who govern and secure AI systems
To certify
An active CISM or CISSP; no separate years-of-experience rule
Exam
90 multiple-choice questions in 150 minutes
Exam fee
US$459 member, US$599 non-member, plus US$50 to apply after passing
Each year after
US$20 member, US$35 non-member; 10 CPE hours a year and 30 every three years

AAIA ISACA

Built for
Auditors who audit AI systems and the controls around them
To certify
An active CISA, or one of ISACA's listed audit and accounting designations (such as CIA, US CPA or ACCA) with an IT audit or advisory role
Exam
90 multiple-choice questions in 150 minutes
Exam fee
US$459 member, US$599 non-member, plus US$50 to apply after passing
Each year after
US$20 member, US$35 non-member; 10 CPE hours a year and 30 every three years

Exam and application fees are in US dollars before tax. ISC2 and ISACA set regional prices and change them, so check the issuer's page before you pay. For full fee breakdowns, see the CISSP cost, CISM cost, CISA cost, AAISM cost and AAIA cost pages.

One problem, three exams, three right answers

The quickest way to see which exam fits you is to watch how each one answers the same situation. This is CertArc's illustration of each exam's point of view, not an exam question.

A cloud storage bucket holding customer records was left publicly readable for three weeks. Your team finds it today. What should happen first?

CISA (auditor)

Tell management at once, so the data owner can close the exposure; the auditor does not fix it. Then establish from evidence when the setting changed, whether the change followed the approved process and whether access was logged, and report the control failure.

CISM (security manager)

Start the incident response process and bring in the data owner, so containment, investigation and any notification follow the organisation's plan and its risk decisions. The manager makes sure the programme responds; it is not a one-person fix.

CISSP (security leader across domains)

Follow the incident response plan: contain the exposure by removing public access, preserve the logs as evidence, then assess what was accessed and notify under the policy. CISSP expects a decision that protects the business and follows its process.

If one of these answers feels obviously right to you, that exam probably matches how you already think. If you keep choosing a different lens from your target exam, plan time to practise its point of view.

Can you sit the exam yet?

You can sit CISSP, CISM and CISA before you have the experience. If you pass CISSP without the five years, you can become an Associate of ISC2, with up to six years to earn the experience, a US$50 annual fee and 15 CPE credits a year. If you already have the experience, ISC2 gives you nine months from your exam date to submit the endorsed application.

ISACA lets you sit CISM or CISA first and apply for the certification within five years of passing. CISM experience must fall within the 10 years before you apply, and ISACA can waive up to two years. CISA allows up to three years to be waived. Students in an ISACA partner program who pass CISA without the experience can also hold the CISA Associate designation for up to four years.

AAISM and AAIA work differently: ISACA opens them only to holders of a qualifying credential. AAISM: An active CISM or CISSP; no separate years-of-experience rule. AAIA: An active CISA, or one of ISACA's listed audit and accounting designations (such as CIA, US CPA or ACCA) with an IT audit or advisory role.

What one certification costs over three years

The exam fee is only the start. This adds the application fee and three annual fees, the first three years of holding one credential, before any training, books or retakes.

CertificationISACA member price (before dues)Standard price
CISSPOne priceUS$1,154
CISMUS$760US$1,065
CISAUS$760US$1,065
AAISMUS$569US$754
AAIAUS$569US$754

Each ISACA certification such as CISM or CISA has its own annual fee; AAISM and AAIA share one fee across all of ISACA's Advanced credentials. The AAISM and AAIA totals are on top of the credential they depend on, which keeps its own fees. ISACA membership has its own dues.

Which order to take them

  • Security manager: CISM, then AAISM

    CISM gives you the eligibility AAISM needs and covers the governance and risk AAISM builds on.

  • Practitioner moving into management: CISSP, then CISM

    CISSP's risk and governance domain overlaps CISM, but CISM asks you to answer as the manager who owns the programme. Read the comparison.

  • Auditor: CISA, then AAIA

    CISA qualifies you for AAIA, and AAIA applies the same audit reasoning to AI systems.

  • Auditor moving into security: CISA, then CISM

    The shift is from judging controls to owning them: expect the right answer to change from report it to run it. Read the comparison.

Already booked and wondering whether you are ready? Am I ready for my exam? shows how to tell from your practice, what to do with the weeks left, and each issuer's rules for moving a date.

Holding one credential and looking at AI next? ISACA AI certifications shows which of ISACA's AI exams your credential opens.

GRC certifications: where these fit

GRC stands for governance, risk and compliance. It is a set of jobs, not one certification. Governance and risk programme roles fit CISM, which tests how a security manager sets direction, runs risk management and reports to leadership. Assurance and compliance testing fit CISA, which tests how an auditor checks that controls work.

ISACA's CRISC is the IT risk credential, and ISC2's CGRC covers governance, risk management and regulatory compliance, including authorizing information systems. CertArc does not prepare for either. For AI governance, AAISM is the step after CISM or CISSP.

Certificate or certification?

A certificate usually means you completed a course or programme, and the provider awards it. A certification such as CISSP, CISM or CISA is awarded by an independent body after you pass its exam, prove qualifying experience, agree to its code of ethics, and then keep it current with continuing education and an annual fee.

Employers tend to read the two differently, so check which one a job advert asks for.

See how each exam thinks before you choose

Each CertArc program has free questions with the full answer review, no sign-up needed. Answer a few from the exam you are considering and see whether its reasoning feels natural.

Questions people ask before choosing

Which cybersecurity certification is best for beginners?

An entry certification such as CompTIA Security+ or ISC2 Certified in Cybersecurity (CC). CISSP, CISM and CISA expect about five years of relevant work experience, and AAISM and AAIA need one of those first.

Is CISM or CISSP better for a management career?

CISM is built for security management: its questions are written from the view of the manager who owns the programme. CISSP covers management too, inside eight broader domains. If you already manage security, CISM fits more directly; if you lead technically and advise management, CISSP does.

Which is harder, CISSP or CISM?

They are hard in different ways. CISSP is broader, covering eight domains in an adaptive exam of 100 to 150 items. CISM is narrower but asks you to choose like a manager when two answers look right. Neither ISC2 nor ISACA publishes a dependable current pass rate; CertArc's CISSP and CISM pass-rate guides explain what is known.

Can I take a certification exam without the experience?

For CISSP, CISM and CISA, yes. You earn the experience afterwards: as an Associate of ISC2 for CISSP, or within ISACA's five-year application window for CISM and CISA, where students in an ISACA partner program can also hold the CISA Associate designation for up to four years. AAISM and AAIA need a qualifying credential first.

Which cybersecurity certification pays the most?

Pay follows the role and your experience more than the credential. In CertArc's view, the useful question is which one the roles you want ask for. CertArc does not promise a salary outcome.

What is the best certification for GRC?

It depends on which part of GRC you do. CISM fits running the security governance and risk programme, and CISA fits assurance and compliance testing. ISC2's CGRC is the credential named for governance, risk and compliance, and ISACA's CRISC is the IT risk credential; CertArc does not prepare for either.

Which AI security certification should I get?

AAISM if you manage AI security and hold CISM or CISSP. AAIA if you audit AI and hold CISA or a listed audit designation. ISACA also offers AAIR for AI risk, which CertArc does not cover.

In what order should I take CISSP, CISM and CISA?

Start with the one that matches your current role, then add the one for the role you are moving into. Common paths are CISSP then CISM for practitioners moving into management, CISA then CISM for auditors moving into security, and CISM or CISA before the AI credentials.

How long does it take to study for these exams?

It depends on how much of the outline your work already covers, so there is no single number. Each CertArc program's study plan spreads its sprints across the time to your exam date, and a free baseline shows which domains need the most time.

Do these certifications expire?

They stay active while you earn continuing professional education and pay the annual fee. CISSP needs 120 CPE credits every three years and US$135 a year. CISM and CISA need 20 CPE hours a year and 120 every three years and US$45 a year for ISACA members or US$85 for non-members. AAISM and AAIA need 10 CPE hours a year and 30 every three years, and one fee of US$20 or US$35 a year covers all of ISACA's Advanced credentials. ISACA members pay less from their third certification.

Is ISACA membership worth it for the exam discount?

ISACA members pay US$575 for CISM or CISA instead of US$760, a saving of US$185, and pay less each year to maintain the certification. Membership has its own annual dues plus any local chapter dues, so compare your total at ISACA's checkout.

Which certifications does CertArc prepare you for?

CISSP, CISM, CISA, AAISM and AAIA. Each program has free practice questions with the full answer review and no sign-up, so you can see how its exam thinks before you choose.

Sources and checks

CertArc is independent and is not affiliated with or endorsed by ISC2 or ISACA. Practice results do not convert to an official score or predict a result.

CertArc

Your whole exam prep. One connected system.

A complete, personalised study system for CISSP, CISM, CISA, AAISM and AAIA: a free baseline, coaching on every answer, and a plan built from your own results.

  • Coaching for the answer you picked
  • Every option compared, side by side
  • A study plan built from your results

21-day free access after onboarding. No credit card required.